Author
|
Conference
|
Journal
|
Organization
|
Year
|
DOI
Look for results that meet for the following criteria:
since
equal to
before
between
and
Search in all domains
Limit my searches in the following domains
Agriculture Science
Arts & Humanities
Biology
Chemistry
Computer Science
Economics & Business
Engineering
Environmental Sciences
Geosciences
Material Science
Mathematics
Medicine
Physics
Social Science
Multidisciplinary
Keywords
(12)
Application Framework
Cognitive Model
Cognitive Science
Command and Control
Conceptual Model
Critical Thinking
Data Collection
Decision Making
Decision Making Process
Human Cognition
Information Need
Mental Representation
Subscribe
Academic
Publications
Modernizing Our Cognitive Model
Edit
Modernizing Our Cognitive Model
(
Citations: 9
)
BibTex
|
RIS
|
RefWorks
Download
David J. Bryant
Although still popular, the Observe-Orient-Decide-Act (OODA) Loop is outdated as a model of human cognition. Based on advances in the cognitive sciences since the 1950s, the Critique- Explore-Compare-Adapt (CECA) Loop is proposed as a better descriptive model. The model puts two mental representations, the
conceptual model
established through operational planning, and the situation model, which represents the state of the battlespace, at the center of the
decision making
process. The four phases of the CECA Loop broadly correspond to the identification of information needs (Critique), active and passive
data collection
and situation updating (Explore), comparison of the current situation to the
conceptual model
(Compare), and adaptation to aspects of the battlespace that invalidate the
conceptual model
or block the path to goal completion (Adapt). The CECA Loop is intended to serve as a simple but widely applicable framework in which to study
decision making
in the context of
Command and Control
(C2). Some advantages of the CECA Loop over the OODA Loop are greater insight into the nature of perception and understanding, introduction of
critical thinking
elements, and exposition of the central role of planning and the
mental representation
of operational concepts in C2.
Cumulative
Annual
View Publication
The following links allow you to view full publications. These links are maintained by other sources not affiliated with Microsoft Academic Search.
(
www.dodccrp.org
)
Citation Context
(6)
...CECA model shows key human activities and a simple representation of estimated states and processing [
21
][6]...
Hossein Parvar
,
et al.
Shared Situation Awareness System Architecture for Network Centric Env...
...The Critique-Explore-Compar loop, introduced in military intelligence rese the OODA loop in order to study the bro Command and Control [8,
27
]...
Ashwin Amanna
,
et al.
Survey of cognitive radio architectures
...The OODA loop has however received criticism over the years for not capturing the goaldirectedness of decision making and for describing only reactive decision making rather than proactive behavior [
5
]...
Lars Niklasson
,
et al.
Extending the scope of situation analysis
...be based on an increased learning cycle [
5
]...
Amir Nasser Shamdani
.
Intelligent Net Centric Command and Control Architecture Using Cogniti...
...Bryant (
Bryant 2004
) has presented a new model (called CECA – Critique, Explore, Compare, Adapt) for military decision-making that better illustrates the relationships between sense making, as described here, and decision making...
Mark Burnett
,
et al.
9th International Command and Control Research and Technology Symposiu...
References
(6)
Essence of Decision: Explaining the Cuban Missile Crisis
(
Citations: 112
)
Graham T Allison
,
Philip Zelikow
Published in 1998.
<i>human problem solving</i
(
Citations: 2932
)
A. Newell
,
H. A. Simon
Published in 1972.
The role of mental models in team performance in complex systems
(
Citations: 113
)
William B. Rouse
,
Janis A. Cannon-Bowers
,
Eduardo Salas
Journal:
IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man and Cybernetics, Part A: Systems and Humans - TSMCA
, vol. 22, no. 6, pp. 1296-1308, 1992
Command and Control for War and Peace
(
Citations: 19
)
Thomas P. Coakley
Published in 1991.
Critical Thinking Skills in Tactical Decision Making: A Model and A Training Strategy
(
Citations: 14
)
Marvin S. Cohen
,
Jared T. Freeman
,
Bryan Thompson
Order by:
Citations
(9)
Shared Situation Awareness System Architecture for Network Centric Environment Decision Making
Hossein Parvar
,
Mehdi N. Fesharaki
,
Behzad Moshiri
Conference:
International Conference on Computer and Network Technology - ICCNT
, 2010
Developing a generic command and control model
Jianying Liu
,
Xiaolong Li
Conference:
International Conference on Computer Science and Information Technology - ICCSIT
, 2010
Survey of cognitive radio architectures
Ashwin Amanna
,
Jeffrey H. Reed
Published in 2010.
THE ROLE OF MENTAL MODELS IN DYNAMIC DECISION-MAKING
Andrea Brown
,
Cheryl Karthaus
,
Lisa Rehak
,
Barb Adams
Published in 2009.
Extending the scope of situation analysis
(
Citations: 1
)
Lars Niklasson
,
Maria Riveiro
,
Fredrik Johansson
,
Anders Dahlbom
,
Göran Falkman
,
Tom Ziemke
,
Christoffer Brax
,
Thomas Kronhamn
,
Martin Smedberg
,
Håkan Warston
,
P. M. Gustavsson
Journal:
Information Fusion - INFFUS
, 2008